How are your NFTs taxed?
Five tax scenarios to keep in mind when buying and selling NFTs
Hey everyone! Good morning!
For all of our active NFT investors and traders, we put together a quick guide of five things for you to keep in mind moving forward! If you’ve read our previous crypto tax guides or seen our recent feature in CoinDesk’s Tax Week, some of this may seem familiar.
If you’re looking for a professional accountant or advisor to help you with taxes or investment planning, we can help! We have a database of over 100 tax and financial pros ready to help you out using Reconcile’s software.
Struggling to keep track of your crypto transactions? We’ve built to help you log all of your taxable trades in a simple spreadsheet.
How are NFTs taxed?
Investing in NFTs may have up to three taxable events.
→ 1st event: Paying with ETH
If an NFT is purchased using crypto such as ether (ETH), this transaction would trigger a capital gain/loss taxable event. The U.S. Internal Revenue Service views this transaction as you selling your ETH for fiat and then using the fiat to buy the NFT, thus creating a taxable event for you. You will be taxed on the price appreciation from when you first bought your ETH to when you "sold" it to buy the NFT.
→ Sold for ETH
If an NFT is sold for crypto such as ETH, or swapped for another NFT, this would trigger a new capital gain/loss taxable event. Similar to the first event, the IRS views this as you selling your NFT for fiat and then rebuying ETH or another NFT with fiat. You will be taxed on the price appreciation of ETH from when you first bought the NFT to when you sold it. So there’s a chance that you sold your NFT for less ETH but still owe taxes because the price of ETH went up from the time you bought the NFT.
→ Back to Fiat
Converting your ETH proceeds from NFT sales back to fiat, you will be taxed on the price appreciation from when you received your ETH proceeds to the current market price at time of fiat conversion.
Creators of NFTs are taxed in a different way from NFT investors. While creating the NFT does not trigger a taxable event, selling an NFT in exchange for crypto or other compensation would. For example, if NFT creators sell a digital collectible for ETH on OpenSea, the creator would be taxed as ordinary income on the compensation received. In this example, if creators do not convert the ETH to U.S. dollars (USD) immediately, a new capital gains holding period begins for the ETH the creators received in the sale.
Taxes on NFT Airdrops
→ What happens if I’m airdropped a token or another NFT because I held the original, like how Bored Ape Yacht Club holders received a Mutant Ape?
This is a scenario with little guidance from the IRS. Based on precedent, airdrops like this will be taxed as ordinary income (i.e., short-term capital gains rates), generally, when the assets are recorded on ledger and/or enter your wallet. So if you don’t claim, you won’t have control of the asset and shouldn’t get taxed. When you sell the airdrop, it’ll be subject to capital gains tax rates.
Note: This isn’t definitive guidance but merely how I and other folks construe the law. For a counterpoint, §1.451-2(a) says, "Income although not actually reduced to a taxpayer's possession is constructively received by him in the taxable year during which it is credited to his account, set apart for him, or otherwise made available so that he may draw upon it at any time, or so that he could have drawn upon it during the taxable year if notice of intention to withdraw had been given.”
With this doctrine, you could be taxed on the value when you could have claimed it, not when you do. However, many airdrops have no liquidity or fair market value, which complicates this even further.
What should I do with worthless NFTs if I was rugged?
Rug pulls aren’t technically considered thefts or scams by the IRS, so there’s no direct rule that helps NFT owners.
So your best bet is to try selling them for 0 ETH on OpenSea or Harvest.art. This way you can at least record a loss that offsets your other capital gains.
Keep in mind, selling NFTs to your friends at a loss in order to tax-loss harvest is potentially tax fraud!
What happens to all the gas fees I paid when buying and selling NFTs?
Just like with commission fees when buying and selling stocks, your crypto gas fees get added to the cost of your transaction (e.g., trade, swap, etc.).
You bought an NFT for 1 ETH and paid .05 in gas fees. Your transaction cost, or cost basis, is now 1.05.
When you sell the NFT, you would consider the purchase price of it to be 1.05 ETH instead of 1.
Note: While the IRS hasn’t explicitly mentioned how crypto gas fees are taxed, we can assume they’ll be included in the cost basis per Publication 551.
Will I pay taxes on NFTs that I’m gifted?
Most likely not! Receiving a gift is not a taxable event. However, the donor will likely owe a “gift tax” if the value is above $16,000 and file IRS Form 709.
However, keep in mind that when you sell your gifted crypto, you’ll owe capital gains tax (if sold at a profit) and your cost basis will be the price at which the original buyer bought it at.
As a disclaimer, please note that the IRS still hasn’t issued crystal clear guidance when it comes to crypto, specifically DeFi and NFTs. Guidance to some of the questions will come from case law and rules for similar assets/investments. Please speak with your tax professional before engaging in any transaction as this is not formal tax advice.